
Wines for the Holidays
6 min read
Wines for the Holidays
Your SLH Guide from Turkey to Tamales
The holiday table is never just one menu. There are turkey and stuffing, sure. There are also tamales steaming on the stove, a platter of lechón, a pot of dumplings, and a cheese board that disappears before anyone sits down. The good news: the Santa Lucia Highlands makes holiday wines for all of it.
This stretch of east-facing benchland above Monterey’s Salinas Valley stays cool and consistent. Every afternoon, wind off Monterey Bay funnels south through the valley and pauses ripening for a few hours. Grapes get a long, steady season, and the wines arrive with ripe flavor and fresh acidity. That balance is exactly what a crowded, many-flavored holiday table needs.
Here is what to pour, why it works, and which bottles are worth wrapping. Keep our Holiday Wine Pairing Cheat Sheet below on the fridge for quick answers.

1. Pinot Noir: The Thanksgiving Turkey's Best Friend
If you pour one wine on Thanksgiving, make it Pinot Noir. Bright acidity and soft tannins won't bury lean white meat, and red cherry and raspberry fruit pick up right where the cranberry sauce leaves off. Earthy, savory notes meet sage, thyme, and mushroom stuffing halfway. CRU Winery's SLH Pinot Noir is an easy crowd-pleaser for a big table. For a bottle from one of the appellation's founding farm families, reach for a Lucia by Pisoni Pinot Noir from the Pisoni family, Rombauer’s Garys’ Vineyard Pinot Noir or ROAR’s Rosella’s Vineyard Pinot Noir.
2. Chardonnay for Everything Buttery
Mashed potatoes and gravy. Green bean casserole. Roasted butternut squash. Thanksgiving sides lean rich, and Santa Lucia Highlands Chardonnay has the texture to match plus the natural acidity to keep every bite fresh. Morgan Winery's Double L Chardonnay comes from the only certified organic vineyard in the appellation. Mer Soleil Chardonnay is easy to grab as it’s widely available in stores across the country. Testarossa brings a bold, rich Chardonnay to the table, along with a variety of Single Vineyard wines. For lighter sides look for an unoaked Chardonnay from Rustiqué.
3. Riesling for the Sweet, the Tart, and the Long Afternoon
Sweet potato casserole, cranberry relish, and honey-glazed ham trip up a lot of reds. Riesling handles them. High acidity balances sweet and tart, and lighter alcohol helps on a day that starts at noon. Riesling is the appellation's lesser-known white, which makes it the bottle your guests haven't tried yet. Look for Morgan's Double L Riesling, the Tondré Grapefield Riesling from Rexford Winery, or Rustiqué Wines, and check out Odonata’s delicious Sparkling Riesling.
4. Bubbles for the Holiday Party
Holiday parties run on appetizers: cheese boards, shrimp cocktail, crab dip, anything fried and salty. Sparkling wine answers all of them. Bubbles and acidity scrub the palate clean after salt and fat, so the next bite tastes as good as the first. Caraccioli Cellars makes traditional-method sparkling wine from its estate Escolle Vineyard and has been named Best U.S. Sparkling Wine at the Champagne & Sparkling Wine World Championships more than once. Puma Road pours a local sparkling wine too, and its Portola Plaza tasting room in downtown Monterey makes an easy stop on a holiday shopping day. Or, head over to Carmel Valley to visit McIntyre Family Wines and try their L’Homme Quit Rit sparkling wine.
5. Hanukkah: Latkes, Brisket, and Eight Nights to Pour
This year, Hanukkah begins at sundown on Friday, December 4, and runs eight nights. The holiday remembers a day’s worth of oil that lasted eight nights, so fried foods take center stage. Crisp potato latkes with applesauce and sour cream call for sparkling wine. Its bubbles and acidity cut through the oil the way a squeeze of lemon would. Chardonnay works too, with enough texture to meet the sour cream. For slow-braised brisket, pour Pinot Noir for bright red fruit or Syrah for savory depth. With eight nights to fill, there’s time to try them all.
6. Syrah for the Bold and The Spiced
Tamales, lechón, roasted lamb, braised short ribs — the richest dishes on a holiday table want a wine with muscle. Santa Lucia Highlands Syrah delivers: deep, inky fruit, black pepper, and a savory finish shaped by the same marine winds that keep the appellation's whites so bright. The cool climate restrains the alcohol and preserves freshness, so it doesn't overwhelm the food.
Syrah is the appellation's most underrated variety and an easy conversation starter at any table. Look for collectibles like Winemaker Bibiana González Rave’s Cattleya Syrah, Morgan's Double L Syrah, which shows the classic Santa Lucia Highlands combination of dark fruit and savory spice, or ROAR's Rosella's Vineyard Syrah for a single-vineyard bottling from one of the appellation's benchmark sites. Either one will hold its own against rich meats and even a little spice.
7. Nochebuena: Tamales, Pozole, and Bacalao
For many Mexican American families, the biggest meal of the season is Nochebuena, the late Christmas Eve dinner. Tamales, red or green pozole, and bacalao (salt cod stewed with tomatoes, olives, and capers) all have a match here.
Pork tamales in red chile work with Pinot Noir, whose fruit and acidity meet the chile without fighting it, or with an off-dry Riesling, whose touch of sweetness cools the heat. Pozole verde and chicken tamales verdes love Chardonnay, Sauvignon Blanc, or sparkling wine, which echo the brightness of tomatillo and lime. Bacalao pairs with Pinot Noir or rosé, both easygoing with tomato and briny olives.
Consdier an earthy Miner Family Wines Pinot Noir, a Grenache or Gamay from Private Property, a mouthwatering Rosé of Pinot Noir from Winemaker Morét Brealynn, or Pessagno, or any one of I. Brand Winery's crisp, refreshing Monterey whites.
8. Asian American Holiday Tables
Many Asian American families blend holiday traditions, and the wine can blend right in. Filipino Noche Buena often centers on lechón or Christmas ham. Sparkling rosé cuts through crackling and fat, and Pinot Noir is a natural with roast pork. Roast duck, a centerpiece at many Chinese American gatherings, is a classic Pinot Noir match.
Dumplings and hot pot pair well with rosé, white wines, or sparkling wine, whose acidity and lack of tannin suit soy, ginger, and chili. Korean galbi and bulgogi meet their match in Pinot Noir's soft tannins and ripe fruit. And for families who celebrate with fried chicken—a Christmas tradition in Japan—pop the bubbles.
9. Wines for the Holidays That Give Back
The best wine gifts come with a story. Some come with a cause. Dawn's Dream Winery was founded around giving: each year its Carmel tasting room features a nonprofit partner, and the winery supports local causes year-round.
Lucy Rosé from the Pisoni family has supported breast cancer charities since 2006. Today, $1 from every bottle goes to breast cancer aid and research. Like the Pisoni family, Scheid Vineyards supports the Monterey Breast Cancer Assistance.
More gift ideas: a magnum of Pinot Noir for the host, a mixed trio of sparkling, Chardonnay, and Pinot Noir, a winery club membership, or a Monterey Pour Pass for a tasting trip in the new year.
10. Small Family Farms, Big Stories
When you pour a Santa Lucia Highlands wine, you pour something grown by people you could meet. Many families here farmed this benchland long before it became an official appellation in 1991. The Franscioni family behind Puma Road traces its roots along the Salinas River to the late 1800s. The Caraccioli family has farmed the area for five generations.
That continuity shows up in the farming. McIntyre Vineyards was among the first in the appellation to earn SIP Certified sustainability status. Pisoni Vineyards devotes an acre to native wildflowers that host beneficial insects—natural pest control in place of sprays. The Lee family has farmed the Morgan Double L Vineyard with organic methods since the beginning. Buying from small wineries means new discoveries for your guests and a bottle you can feel good about opening.
Pour Local This Season
Holiday wines don't need to be complicated. Match bright with rich, bubbles with salt, and a little sweetness with a little heat. Pour something local, tell the story behind the bottle, and plan a visit in the new year. Find tasting rooms and order direct through our your favorite local winery, grab the Holiday Wine Pairing Cheat Sheet, and sign up for the SLH Lowdown for member news and holiday offers.
Stay Connected
Join the Conversation
One email a month. Never more. Privacy Policy
